Tags
Tab Item Content
Join Us!
Archives Meta
Notifications
Clear all

are buddhist & Christians compatible? are vietnamese and Filipinos compatible?

13 Posts
7 Users
3 Likes
1,889 Views
josh avatar
Posts: 4380
Registered
Topic starter
(@zexsypmp23)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Then you have zero to no idea about Christian and Vietnamese culture. The Vietnamese worship their ancestors while Christian does not allow to workship ancestors, many Vietnamese refuse to become Christian for that reason. Many Viet practice Catholic and also worship their ancestors they combine the two.

That is only one of the examples of conflicts between culture, religion, and identity.

The case of Korean were nomad people and had weak religious. That can explain the fast rate adoption of Christianity.

The Japanese have a strong Shinto religion that can explain low Christian adoption.

The Japanese still using Kanji based on Chinese characters, because Chinese was not a threat to their identity.

Vietnamese abandoned Han-Viet to adopt Latin based because they have always wanted a separate identity.

English is treated as the second linguist in Vietnam even though there are not many English live in Vietnam because they don't see English as a threat but economic opportunities. This contrary to how French was perceived during Indo-China war.

here is my intake, Most Christian has no problem with Buddhists, in fact of all the non-Abrahamic religions around the world. I say Buddhists are the most tolerable here why.

1)Buddhism is more of a cultural philosophy/enlightenment & not a religion that deals with a God deity. ( my definition of Buddhism is atheist)

2)Buddhism's definition of worshipping ancestors isn't the same as the definition of Abrahamic worship of God. ( Buddhist doesn't treat your great father as the creator of the universe)

3)budda's concept of God is that God is everywhere in the water, trees, animals. ( same kami beliefs like Japanese).

For Christians, Christians call it the '' holy spirit of God'' holy spirit can move the waters. holds everything on its place & it's everywhere.

Reply
12 Replies
4 Replies
Antipolo
(@jun)
Joined: 5 years ago

Reputable Member
Posts: 229
Posted by: @rambo

Then you have zero to no idea about Christian and Vietnamese culture. The Vietnamese worship their ancestors while Christian does not allow to workship ancestors, many Vietnamese refuse to become Christian for that reason. Many Viet practice Catholic and also worship their ancestors they combine the two.

That is only one of the examples of conflicts between culture, religion, and identity.

The case of Korean were nomad people and had weak religious. That can explain the fast rate adoption of Christianity.

The Japanese have a strong Shinto religion that can explain low Christian adoption.

The Japanese still using Kanji based on Chinese characters, because Chinese was not a threat to their identity.

Vietnamese abandoned Han-Viet to adopt Latin based because they have always wanted a separate identity.

English is treated as the second linguist in Vietnam even though there are not many English live in Vietnam because they don't see English as a threat but economic opportunities. This contrary to how French was perceived during Indo-China war.

here is my intake, Most Christian has no problem with Buddhists, in fact of all the non-Abrahamic religions around the world. I say Buddhists are the most tolerable here why.

1)Buddhism is more of a cultural philosophy/enlightenment & not a religion that deals with a God deity. ( my definition of Buddhism is atheist)

2)Buddhism's definition of worshipping ancestors isn't the same as the definition of Abrahamic worship of God. ( Buddhist doesn't treat your great father as the creator of the universe)

3)budda's concept of God is that God is everywhere in the water, trees, animals. ( same kami beliefs like Japanese).

For Christians, Christians call it the '' holy spirit of God'' holy spirit can move the waters. holds everything on its place & it's everywhere.

Buddhism is still under paganism , worshiping ancestors is no different than worshiping kings and emperors.

Buddhism is very materialistic.

Reply
josh avatar
Registered
(@zexsypmp23)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 4380

@jun

how is Buddhism materialistic?

Reply
ARZ
 ARZ
(@arz)
Joined: 5 years ago

Estimable Member
Posts: 79

We worship God for love as in Father and Son relationship. Buddhist worship their ancestors for money.

Reply
josh avatar
Registered
(@zexsypmp23)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 4380

@arz

 

yeah you are right

 

Reply
ciccotelli avatar
Posts: 400
(@ciccotelli)
Honorable Member
Joined: 4 years ago

I'm very curious about Buddhism.

Reply
josh avatar
Posts: 4380
Registered
Topic starter
(@zexsypmp23)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago


Christianity Chinese according to BBC, the unofficial number is somewhere 400 millions from 1 million 30 years ago. The craziest adoption rate.

Vietnam since Christianity introduced in the 16th century which was 500 years ago now has under 10% combine of Catholic and Protestant.

Meanwhile Buddhism Vietnam there are many big temples have been built. If the Chinese is a strong Buddhism country with 1.2 billion, the number of temples should be 10x Vietnam but that is not the case. This means China does not has strong religious culture foundation.

the massive scale temples that could only be achieved when a country has strong support from followers. Find me are there many Chinese temples surpassed this scale?

Reply
josh avatar
Posts: 4380
Registered
Topic starter
(@zexsypmp23)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

That is not true. Japanese was the country more open to the West than both China and Vietnam. They welcomed Western influence during the Meiji period. Christianity is widely adopted in Japan because they already have a strong religious foundation.

Vietnam was a country strongly against the adoption of Christianity under Ming Mang but that does not stop Christianity spreading what slow down the adoption of Christianity in Vietnam is nothing other than Buddhism.

Just ask yourself, would you adopt another religion if your belief already in another?

Ask another question, would you adopt a religion if you have none?

That is really simple.

400 million is an unofficial number according to BBC. Heck 1 million to 120 million in 30 years already massive adoption rate already.

Reply
josh avatar
Posts: 4380
Registered
Topic starter
(@zexsypmp23)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

The religious foundation I am talking about here is a country with a strong dominant religion be that Islam, Buddhist, Christian, shinto...etc. Chinese just don't simply have a strong religion but Vietnam do and that is Buddhism.

I already pointed out a few things about why the Chinese don't have a strong religion.
- The fast adoption rate of Christian followers.
- The population of 1.2 billion has fewer large temples than Vietnam which population only 90 million, this means there aren't a strong number of followers/supporters.

In the near future, I am sure the Christian followers in China will become the largest Christian country.

Vietnam majority Christians are Roman Catholic, unlike China and Korea mostly are protestants/Baptists. Protestants/Baptists is a recent split from Roman Catholic. U.S. has high percent Protestants/Baptists

Conquest or not conquest does not change much. Vietnam was colonized by French for a century, Christianity introduced to Vietnam 200 years before the French colonization and to this day the Christian followers less than 10% . Why the adoption rate is slow? Despite the fact, Vietnam was a French colony, despite the fact Christian was introduced in an early time 500 years ago, despite the fact, American came to contact Vietnam 10 years.

S.Korea only recently opened to the world and recently came contact with the American and the followers jumped to 30% population.

Look at the Thai, they have been pro-west since the 18th century and the Christians followers are 1.2%. You could guess why?

Reply
Page 1 / 2