Tags
Tab Item Content
Join Us!
Archives Meta
Notifications
Clear all

Difference between modern and early modern Ao-dai

8 Posts
1 Users
0 Reactions
1,940 Views
Doraemon
Posts: 96
Topic starter
(@doraemon)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Most people think of ao-dai as the traditional attire of Vietnam, but not many realize that the tailoring of ao-dai today is drastically different from the tailoring of ao-dai in the early 20th century and earlier. 

Early modern ao-dai followed the tailoring techniques common in the Sinospheric countries. Two pieces of fabrics were sewn together at the body midline, forming the front flap, and same for the back flap. Often an attire was made of two layers of fabrics stitched together (in the case of Japan, four layers, that's why kimonos always looks thicker than attires from Korea, China, or Vietnam). Some features distinguishing early modern ao-dai from its modern counterpart:

1) The shoulder line of early modern is straight when spread out.
2) The armpit area of early modern ao dai is wide regardless of whether the sleeves are narrow or loose (this was because people back then often wore more than one layer of clothes, the wide armpit area was to accommodate the many clothes they wore). 
3) From top down in early modern ao dai, the body piece always gets much wider. In modern ao dai, the body is almost straight from top down.
4) Early modern ao dai did not have raglan sleeves like modern ao dai. 

Modern ao dai has been influenced by tailoring techniques from the West


Modern ao dai spread out


Early modern ao dai spread out (20th century). Technically it should be called "áo ngũ thân" - the progenitor of what we call ao-dai today.


A variation of áo ngũ thân with wide sleeves. 20th century, Nguyen dynasty, Vietnam.

Early modern aodai was similar to earlier attires in term of structure


From top down: 1) 18th century cross-necked robe (called áo giao lĩnh) of Lê dynasty, Vietnam. 2) 20th century imperial attire of Nguyễn dynasty, Vietnam. 3) 18th century round-necked robe (called áo viên lĩnh) of Lê dynasty, Vietnam.


Nhật Bình jacket of Nguyen dynasty, Vietnam.


Nguyen dynasty ceremonial robe


Nguyen dynasty mandarin robe


Nguyen dynasty mandarin robes

Reply
7 Replies
Doraemon
Posts: 96
Topic starter
(@doraemon)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Here are a couple old photographs. The first one is probably the oldest. The sleeves on that one are still wide, whereas the others are tight.



In certain Highschools in Saigon, girls wear white ao dai everyday to school. In Hanoi, they wear it during graduation. Women's ao dai can take the place of formal evening dresses. For men, ao dai is typically only worn during special occasions like weddings and new year events.

Students in ao dai:

Calligrapher wearing ao dai during lunar new year.



Yes. Up until the late 50s, the early modern style was still common. Here are some pictures of people wearing it. 

^ Notice the seam line running down the front flap (there is one for the back flap too). In traditional tailoring technique, the body piece was formed by two pieces of fabrics sewn together. You no longer see it today. 

On the other hand, the front and back flap (of the same side) were one piece, so you would not see seam line running along shoulders like in today garments. 



I know you will say, "but they don't look the same". Well, some of them are looser and have wider sleeves than others but they all follow the same tailoring formula and have the same structures (for example: the body piece is always at wider at the bottom than at the top). 

Even these mandarin robes were tailored using the same formula. 



Reply
Doraemon
Posts: 96
Topic starter
(@doraemon)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

I've already mentioned this difference. 

In early modern attires, the bottom of the body piece is always wide relatively to the top

In modern aodai, the bottom of the body piece is as narrow as the top. 

Reply
Doraemon
Posts: 96
Topic starter
(@doraemon)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Fourth difference is the fabric

Tailors and designers often choose thin, flowy fabrics to for aodai today. 

But these fabrics were not common in the old days. 

The materials back then were often thicker, either made of ramie (for low class) or silks (for high class). 

vs

Reply
Doraemon
Posts: 96
Topic starter
(@doraemon)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Ironically, what these girls wear look more similar to early modern ao dai imo because 1) the flaps do not reach the floor like in aodai you see today, 2) the bottom of the body piece is relatively wide

Reply
Page 1 / 2