Tags
Tab Item Content
Join Us!
Archives Meta
Notifications
Clear all

When Thai/Tai think of Vietnamese

22 Posts
8 Users
10 Reactions
1,697 Views
josh avatar
Posts: 4380
Registered
Topic starter
(@zexsypmp23)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Historically, the original Viet/Kinh before been rules by Han-Chinese were considered as Austro-Asiatic which is the same group as Mon-khmer. I red that they originated in Southeas Asia around Red River Delta. The thing that make Viet/Kinh a little bit diffrent from other Mon-Khmer ethnics is they have been rule by Han-Chinese for like 1000 years, So that will explains why they looks diffrent from other Austro-Asiatic (Mon-khmer) ethnics and with heavily influenced of Han-Chinese culture.

By the way the Thai/Dai are originated in South of China and considered as Tai-Kadai ethnic, but move down to Southeast Asia in 13th century. Also the original Tai/Dai genetic are also closely related with in Zhuang/Cantonese in China. Tai/Dai never be invade and rule by Han-Chinese just like Hmong and Zhuang, so culturally their culture aren't close to Han-Chinese culture. By the way genetically they seem to be obviously related to Northeast Asian not any less than Vietnamese. Also Thailand is currently world's bigest Han-Chinese Comunity outside of China, there are 9.5 millions of pure 100% Han-Chinese. Also estimated over 50% of total population are Han-Chinese hybird (30million are Thai-Chinese). So genetically I think Thai are more related to Chinese than Vietnamese .

By the way culturally Vietnamese is obviously more related to Han-Chinese than Thai, but not genetically.
Genetically and culturally is diffrent story and have to be divide apart.

Tai-kadai people were weak and lake in culture, so in the time they move down to Southeast Asia and war with native people of Indo-Chia which is Khmer. Tai-kadai seem to be absorbed into Khmer culture because Khmer civilization on that time were considered as powerful and rich in culture. So this would explains why modern day Thai/Dai in Thailand and Laos are influenced by Khmer culturally.

This is really same case as how Mongolian conquered China but on that time the Mongolian were weak and lake in culture, by the way Han-Chinese were powerful and rich in culture. So those Mongolian obviously absorbed into Han-Chinese culture.

Reply
21 Replies
4 Replies
Komodo Commander
(@komodo)
Joined: 5 years ago

Noble Member
Posts: 943

@rambo

I don't think Thais came from China. 

Reply
Sharpshooter avatar
(@dadadas)
Joined: 5 years ago

Honorable Member
Posts: 505
Posted by: @zexsypmp23

Historically, the original Viet/Kinh before been rules by Han-Chinese were considered as Austro-Asiatic which is the same group as Mon-khmer. I red that they originated in Southeas Asia around Red River Delta. The thing that make Viet/Kinh a little bit diffrent from other Mon-Khmer ethnics is they have been rule by Han-Chinese for like 1000 years, So that will explains why they looks diffrent from other Austro-Asiatic (Mon-khmer) ethnics and with heavily influenced of Han-Chinese culture.

By the way the Thai/Dai are originated in South of China and considered as Tai-Kadai ethnic, but move down to Southeast Asia in 13th century. Also the original Tai/Dai genetic are also closely related with in Zhuang/Cantonese in China. Tai/Dai never be invade and rule by Han-Chinese just like Hmong and Zhuang, so culturally their culture aren't close to Han-Chinese culture. By the way genetically they seem to be obviously related to Northeast Asian not any less than Vietnamese. Also Thailand is currently world's bigest Han-Chinese Comunity outside of China, there are 9.5 millions of pure 100% Han-Chinese. Also estimated over 50% of total population are Han-Chinese hybird (30million are Thai-Chinese). So genetically I think Thai are more related to Chinese than Vietnamese .

By the way culturally Vietnamese is obviously more related to Han-Chinese than Thai, but not genetically.
Genetically and culturally is diffrent story and have to be divide apart.

Tai-kadai people were weak and lake in culture, so in the time they move down to Southeast Asia and war with native people of Indo-Chia which is Khmer. Tai-kadai seem to be absorbed into Khmer culture because Khmer civilization on that time were considered as powerful and rich in culture. So this would explains why modern day Thai/Dai in Thailand and Laos are influenced by Khmer culturally.

This is really same case as how Mongolian conquered China but on that time the Mongolian were weak and lake in culture, by the way Han-Chinese were powerful and rich in culture. So those Mongolian obviously absorbed into Han-Chinese culture.

lol xunlao. That guy isnt even a Thai.

 

Reply
josh avatar
Registered
(@zexsypmp23)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 4380

@dadadas Chinese Thai?

Reply
josh avatar
Registered
(@zexsypmp23)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 4380

@dadadas I think Winner wrote that not Xun Lao.

Reply
jason
Posts: 813
(@jason)
Prominent Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Are they the same people? 

Reply
4 Replies
Rick Cool
(@rick-cook)
Joined: 6 years ago

Noble Member
Posts: 1131

@jason

depends, Vietnamese are diverse people. They can look from Thai/Filipinos to Chinese looking. 

Reply
josh avatar
Registered
(@zexsypmp23)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 4380

@jason

I'll make a thread so Filipinos can understand the other ASEAN members 

 

Reply
KAY avatar
 kay
(@kay)
Joined: 5 years ago

Prominent Member
Posts: 729

@rambo

The Vietnamese that border China looks like the Chinese but the Vietnamese that's live near Thailand look more like us. 

Reply
josh avatar
Registered
(@zexsypmp23)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 4380

@kay

Yes, including northern Laos and people from Myanmar look like part Indian. 

Reply
athena
Posts: 943
(@athena)
Noble Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Tay a minority group in Vietnam are thought to be Tai ethnic in Thailand. They came from Southern china but they are not chines. They integrate well with Kinh ethnics throughout history and many intermariages. You can see their custumes look very similar to ao dai. 

 

https://www.amazians.com/forum/?foro=resetpassword&rp_key=aQUs7bG6gLVoXAGz4vTX&rp_login=athena

Reply
2 Replies
josh avatar
Registered
(@zexsypmp23)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 4380

@athena isn't Kinh another word for Tai? l

Reply
James avatar
(@james)
Joined: 5 years ago

Noble Member
Posts: 1715

@zexsypmp23 Tai are minority absorbed by Kinh

Reply
James avatar
Posts: 1715
(@james)
Noble Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Vietnamese are Tai 😆 

Reply
Sharpshooter avatar
Posts: 505
(@dadadas)
Honorable Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Viets are very independent minded people whose ancestors fought against Imperial Chinese army from South-western China & Eastern China to found their own kingdom.

Thais are Chinese asskissers whose ancestors took advantage of a weakened Khmer empire to found their kingdom.

Reply
1 Reply
James avatar
(@james)
Joined: 5 years ago

Noble Member
Posts: 1715

@dadadas ladyboy land. What do you expect 😆

Reply
Page 1 / 2